INNO Appraisal Template Final 071214 Empty

of 8
13 views
PDF
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Document Description
Appraisal Template Information about the Template and the Project The INNO-Appraisal initiative aims to contribute to the creation, consolidation and strengthening of an evaluation culture in Europe and to learning about good practice in innovation policy making. INNO-Appraisal takes stock of innovation appraisal exercises such as evaluations and monitoring, benchmarking and peer review reports in the area of innovation policy. It seeks to characterise and assess appraisals and utilise appraisal
Document Share
Document Tags
Document Transcript
   page 1 of 8 Information about the Template and the Project The INNO-Appraisal initiative aims to contribute to the creation, consolidation and strengthening of an evaluation culture inEurope and to learning about good practice in innovation policy making. INNO-Appraisal takes stock of innovation appraisal exercises such as evaluations and monitoring, benchmarking and peer reviewreports in the area of innovation policy. It seeks to characterise and assess appraisals and utilise appraisal reports for policylearning . The study is funded by the European Commission, DG Enterprise. This template is the primary instrument for the collection of information and the assessment of individual appraisals ofinnovation policies and programmes. It will be a part of a repository that will be stored on the public PRO INNO Europewebsite. ( http://www.proinno-europe.eu/)We are not interested in appraisals at the individual project level, rather we are restricting our analysis to appraisals at the policymeasure (programme) level . Our starting point for identifying evaluated measures is the INNO-Policy TrendChart innovationpolicy measures database.We hope to derive lessons for innovation policy formulation and implementation from the appraisal of the specific policymeasure.The purpose of this template is to characterise and assess one specific appraisal exercise in the context of one particularinnovation policy measure/programme . (Please do not consider the role of other appraisals in relation to this specific innovationpolicy measure.)The appraisal covered in this template isThe innovation policy measure assessed by this appraisal isWe kindly ask you  , as one of the policy-makers or administrators responsible for the innovation policy measure concerned, to helpus complete these templates .These short instructions are designed to reduce your workload as much as possible: 1 . Most of this form has been pre-filled by our project team, relying on information contained in the relevant appraisal report(s);  2. Please complete the fields we have not pre-filled;3 . Please briefly check our pre-filled answers and correct them if needed;4 . If you do correct a prefilled answer, you may comment on your reason in the box provided  ;5. You can save this questionnaire at any time and continue to complete it at your convenience. To do so, please use the File >> Savemenu in your reader.  6. Please return the completed template by attaching it to an e-mail and sending it to the following e-mail address:   Thank you for your co-operation. You will receive a note once the analysis is complete and has been uploadedto the website. Please feel free to make comments or requests to us any time.The more policy-makers participate,the greater the benefit for the policy-making community in Europe! Appraisal Template   page 2 of 8 Part A: Information about the Respondent A.1.a. First name A.1.b. Last name A.1.c. Affiliation and position   Position, Unit/Department, Institution/Ministry A.1.e. E-mail address A.1.d. Address A.1.f. Telephone number B.1.b. Country and name of the measure that the appraisalevaluated (Only if the measure is not listed in B.1.a.) B.1.a. Trendchart code and title of the corresponding policymeasure Part B: Corresponding Policy MeasurePart C: Characteristics of the Appraisal (while answering this part please consider the primary policy measure indicated in part B) C.1.a. Who conducted the appraisal?   You can select more than one option by using the ctrl key. C.1.b. Participating institutions in the appraisal exercise   If there is a leading institution, please put it first. C.1.c. E-mail address of the corresponding evaluator C.2.a. Tender Procedure C.3.d. Any Comments? C.3.a. Timing of the appraisal C.3.b. Purpose of the appraisal C.4.c. Any Comments? C.4.a. Was this appraisal a condition of external/international(co)sponsorship (e.g. EU, World Bank, etc.) of the measure? C.4.b. If your answer to C.4.a. is Yes, please name the sponsor.Pre-filled by (Office use only)Sent by (Office use only) C.3.c. If your answer to C.3.b. is Other , please specify.   page 3 of 8 Part C: Characteristics of the Appraisal (continued from previous page) (while answering this part please consider the primary policy measure indicated in part B) C.5.a. Does   the policy measure has a dedicated budget forappraisal? C.6.a. Was the   appraisal, to which this template refers, foreseenand planned for during the design phase of the measure?(please tick if your answer is yes)   C.6.b. I f your answer to C.6.a is no, what prompted the appraisal? C.6.c. Any Comments? C.7. Topics covered in the appraisal (Questions that the appraisal aims to answer) Covered in the Appraisal C.7.a. External Consistency (If the measure's goals were appropriate and consistent with the externalchallenges the measure was meant to address) C.7.b. Internal Consistency (If the measure's modalities were appropriate and consistent with its goals) C.7.c. Coherence/Complementarity (Whether the measure was coherent with, and complementary to, otherprogrammes and policy initiatives) C.7.d. Goal Attainment/Effectiveness (If the goals of the measure were achieved) C.7.e. Outputs, Outcomes and Impacts (The consequences or results of the measure) C.7.f. Quality of Outputs (Whether the outputs of projects were of a high quality) C.7.g. Value for Money / Return on Investment/Cost-Benefit Efficiency (If there were adequate returns oninvestment) C.7.h. Programme Implementation Efficiency (If the measure was well-managed) C.7.i. Project Implementation Efficiency (If projects supported by the measure were well-managed) C.7.j. Input Additionality (If the measure stimulated more investment in innovation than would haveoccurred in the absence of the measure) C.7.k. Output Additionality (If the measure stimulated more innovation outputs than would have occurredin the absence of the measure) C.7.l. Behavioural Additionality (If the measure stimulated persistent changes in the behaviours of theparticipants that would have not occurred in the absence of the measure) C.7.m. Policy/Strategy Development (Implications for future strategy development and policy formulation) C.7.n. Gender issues C.7.o. Minority issues C.7.p. Other: C.7.q. Any Comments? C.5.c. Any Comments? C.5.b. Cost of the appraisal as a percentage of the budget of themeasure (or in absolute terms in Euro).   page 4 of 8 Part C: Characteristics of the Appraisal (continued from previous page) (while answering this part please consider the primary policy measure indicated in part B) C.8.g. Any Comments? C.8. Did the appraisal look at the following impacts?C.8.a. Scientific C.8.b. Technological C.8.c. Economic C.8.d. Social C.8.e. Environmental C.8.f. Other: C.9. Sponsor(s) of the appraisalC.9.a. Programme Owner/Manager C.9.b. Other Government Department C.9.c. Other Public Bodies (e.g. court of auditors, parliament committee) C.9.d. Other: C.9.e. Any Comments? C.12. Data analysis method employed in the appraisalC.12.a. Case Study Analysis C.12.b. Network Analysis C.12.c. Econometric Analysis C.12.d. Descriptive Statistics (e.g. uptake analysis) C.12.e. Input/Output Analysis C.12.f. Document Analysis C.12.g. Context Analysis C.12.h. Before/After Group Comparison Approach C.12.i. Control Group Approach C.12.j. Counter-Factual Approach C.12.k. Cost/Benefit Approach C.12.l. Other: C.12.m. Any Comments? C.10.a. Publication date of the appraisal report C.10.b. Start date of the period covered by the appraisal C.10.c. End date of the period covered by the appraisal C.11.a. Availability of the appraisal report C.11.c. URL of the Report C.11.b. Language of the appraisal report
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks
SAVE OUR EARTH

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!

x